Butterfly valves in large diameter lines

Above about DN 300 the economics of valve selection change. A gate or ball valve at DN 1000 is a massive casting, heavy to lift, expensive to buy and slow or costly to operate. A butterfly valve of the same size is a short ring of metal with a disc in the middle, a fraction of the weight, driven by a modest gearbox or actuator. That is why water treatment works, cooling water systems, power station circulating water lines and large air and gas ducts are full of butterfly valves, and why the design deserves more engineering attention than its simple appearance suggests.

Why the butterfly takes over in big pipe

The face to face dimension of a butterfly valve barely grows with diameter compared with a gate valve. The body is essentially a short spool holding a seat, and the disc rotates a quarter turn on a shaft across the bore. Material goes into the disc and shaft rather than into a large pressure retaining body cavity. At large diameters the saving is enormous in weight, in support steel, in crane capacity during installation and in the space the valve occupies in a crowded valve chamber.

Operation is quarter turn, so a worm gearbox gives the mechanical advantage needed for manual operation and an actuator only has to turn ninety degrees. A gate valve of the same bore needs many turns of a stem and a long bonnet, often with a rising stem that stands well above the pipe.

The cost of that compactness is a disc that remains in the flow when the valve is open. It adds head loss, though at large diameter this is usually small compared with the line itself, and it rules out pigging. In slurry and abrasive service the disc edge and seat erode quickly.

Concentric, double offset and triple offset

Three geometries cover most applications, and the difference between them is how the disc meets the seat.

The concentric or resilient seated valve has the shaft on the centreline of both disc and bore. The disc edge squeezes into an elastomer liner, usually EPDM or nitrile, which seals it and often also lines the body so the fluid never touches the metal. It is cheap and tight, and it dominates water and low pressure utility service. In North American waterworks, AWWA C504 covers rubber seated butterfly valves. Pressure and temperature are limited by the elastomer, and the disc rubs the liner through the last part of closure, so wear and torque both rise with age.

The double offset or high performance valve moves the shaft behind the sealing plane and slightly off the pipe centreline. The disc lifts away from the seat almost as soon as it starts to open, so rubbing is confined to the last few degrees of travel. Seats are usually reinforced PTFE, sometimes with a metal backup ring for fire safety. These valves handle Class 150 and Class 300 hydrocarbon and steam duties that a lined valve cannot.

The triple offset adds a third offset, a conical sealing geometry inclined to the bore axis. The disc seal ring meets the seat only at the end of travel, without rubbing, and the seal is made by torque rather than by interference. Metal to metal seating makes these valves fire safe by design and suitable for high temperature steam, hot gas and cryogenic duty. They are torque seated, so the actuator must be set to drive into the seat, and most have a preferred flow direction in which the seal is tighter.

Type Typical seat Typical duty Main limitation
Concentric EPDM or nitrile liner Water, cooling water, low pressure air Elastomer temperature and chemical resistance
Double offset Reinforced PTFE Class 150 and 300 process, moderate steam Polymer seat temperature
Triple offset Laminated or solid metal High temperature, fire safe, cryogenic Cost, preferred direction, torque setting

Industrial butterfly valves in Europe are generally built to EN 593, and in oil and gas to API 609, which covers both the lined and the offset categories.

Torque is the real design problem

On a large butterfly valve, sizing the operator is the engineering task, and it is where most failures begin. Three torque components add together.

Seating and unseating torque is the friction of disc against seat at the closed position. In a lined valve it is the dominant term and grows as the elastomer ages and hardens. Bearing torque comes from differential pressure acting on the disc area and being reacted through the shaft bearings, so it rises with the square of diameter and with pressure difference. Dynamic torque comes from the flow itself. Liquid passing around a partly open disc creates unequal pressure distributions on the two halves, and on a symmetric disc the resulting moment tends to close the valve. It peaks at an intermediate opening, not at fully open or closed.

Dynamic torque is the term people forget. A valve that strokes easily during a factory test, or during commissioning with the line static, can stall or be driven shut at part opening under full pump flow. The supplier should provide a torque curve across the whole stroke at the actual design flow and differential pressure, and the operator should be sized against the highest point on that curve with a sensible safety factor. Worm gearboxes on manual valves should be self locking, so the flow cannot back drive the disc.

Throttling, closure time and surge

A butterfly valve can throttle, and large ones often do, on pump discharge and on flow balancing. The useful control range is narrower than a globe valve’s. Near closed the flow area changes very fast for a small rotation and the jet attacks the seat. Near fully open the disc has little effect on flow. Keeping normal operation in the middle of the rotation helps, as does a valve sized below line size. Above a certain pressure drop the downstream side cavitates, which in a large valve is loud and destructive. The butterfly valve was never meant to be a precision control element, and a standard one should not be sold as such.

Closure time matters more on large lines than almost anywhere else, because the momentum of a big water column is enormous. A quarter turn valve shut in a few seconds on a long main produces a pressure transient that can exceed the pipe rating. Most of the effective flow reduction happens in the final part of the stroke, so a uniform closing rate wastes time early and closes too fast late. The usual answer on pumping mains is a two speed closure, fast over the first part of travel and slow over the last, using hydraulic actuators or electric actuators with adjustable speed. A surge analysis should set the closing time, not the actuator catalogue.

Installation points for big valves

  • Check disc clearance. The open disc projects beyond the body faces and can strike an adjacent check valve, reducer or lined pipe whose bore is smaller than the valve expects.
  • Install the shaft horizontal in lines carrying solids, so sediment does not pack into the lower bearing.
  • Fit triple offset valves in their preferred direction wherever shutoff matters, and show it on the drawings.
  • Keep elbows and pump outlets well upstream, because a skewed velocity profile raises dynamic torque and causes disc flutter.
  • Support heavy actuators and gearboxes independently on very large valves rather than hanging them off the shaft.
Tags: No tags

Comments are closed.